728x90

Parent Moments: Saying Goodnight to Maggie-Dog

full star full star full star empty star empty star Rated by 12 members
Everyone has their story about the hilarious and humbling experience of raising children. Share yours by adding a quick comment at the bottom of this article; if we like your comment best, you could win a great prize!
Learn More

The Prize: WannaBe bag by Ju-Ju-Be

Related articles:

Eight years have passed, but it doesn't take much to plunge me into guilt over putting our dog Maggie to sleep. Saying goodbye to a pet who is suffering is one thing, but this was different.

Matt and I adopted Maggie -- a skittish mutt from the pound with a herder's aggressive mentality -- two years before our first children were born. She was anxious from the start, and would round up and dominate any dog who would let her. This led to a couple of ugly skirmishes, and soon I kept Maggie on the leash and avoided parks where dogs played off-leash.

Then Matt and I learned I was pregnant with twins. We had no idea what to expect from Maggie (never mind how to manage two babies); all we could do was be prepared. I found a professional trainer who specialized in aggressive dogs. He taught me to work with her instincts, told me she needed a "job," and that we needed to assume control as the head honchos of her "pack." We worked hard with him every week, and faithfully practiced our lessons twice a day. We played tapes of crying babies to get her used to the sound. When the girls were born, my husband brought home some of their tiny clothes so Maggie could get used to their smell.

It paid off. Maggie was wonderful around Caitlin and Ellie, accepting them into the fold without question. She slept by their cribs at night in the room next to ours, and walked with me twice a day alongside the stroller. The only trouble was, she took her new role as mother's helper a little too seriously and became more protective of her pack than ever. She seemed to feel a responsible for keeping visitors in line, and would especially follow our guy friends around, walking right at their heels. On occasion, she'd nip at the back of their knees. In hindsight, these were red flags we should have taken more seriously, if not for the complete sleep deficit and overwhelming nature of life with twin infants.

When our girls were 18 months old, we left urban Massachusetts for the Maine coast. Maggie, we figured, would thrive here too, with a huge yard to roam and a roomy house instead of a cramped 2nd floor apartment. But the space and quiet overwhelmed her. It was as if there was too much turf to guard and protect and she couldn't possibly cover it all. What's more, Caitlin and Ellie were no longer infants in bassinets. They had to be tracked, too, and they were constantly moving, often in opposite directions.

Maggie had two more significant clashes with other dogs. We hired another trainer. We tried a low-protein diet to lower her energy levels. We experimented with various collars. Gave her "jobs" by having her fetch, and learn more commands. Nothing solved her issues, but we were still hopeful.

Then came the day Maggie snapped at Ellie, and I knew we'd reached the point of no return. I don't know what provoked her. I was in the family room, with Maggie and the girls at the foot of the couch on the floor. Out of the blue, she turned and quickly snapped her jaws, catching Ellie's leg. No blood, no broken skin, but a line had clearly been crossed. Although I knew what had to happen, it didn't seem fair for us to play God with her life.

I spoke with our vet. I consulted more trainers. But our options seemed few. Who wanted a dog that bites? In the end, I cried a lot and made an appointment at the vet to have her put to sleep. When the dreaded day arrived, I dropped the girls at our sitter's house and drove with Maggie to the vet. She walked in, completely trusting, and minutes later got stuck with a needle and slipped away. I left in a wash of tears and haven't been able to set foot in that building since.

As I write this, my eyes brim again as the guilt and sadness return, fresh as if this were yesterday. I know I had to do what we did for the sake of our family's safety, but I don't think I'll ever feel right about ending her life. The vet sent her ashes to us. They are still sitting in our hall closet. I can't bring myself to bury her.

Two years later, we adopted another dog, a 3-year-old black Lab whose family had seen one too many trash cans dumped and had no time to get him the exercise he craved. We knew Trapper's family, so there were no wild guesses about his background or personality. He has his warts: Left to his own devices, he'll eat unlimited quantities of anything from zucchini to birdseed. He likes to bark at the FedEx guy, which sends me into fits of worry. But he is nothing but gentle with children. We adore him back. And so I hold onto my happier memories of Maggie, and try to find some redemption in the thought that we've given another misfit a home.


How about you? What role do pets play in your family's life?

Learn More About the Comment Mania! Contest
Bookmark and Share

Member Comments On...

Parent Moments: Saying Goodnight to Maggie-Dog

JeanDB08
JeanDB08 says:
July 24, 2008

I can identify with what Tracy went through in training a herding dog. We got our 13 y.o. Border Collie/Chow Chow mix, Lea, right after we were married. It took a few months of leash work, stare-downs & wrestling to establish the fact that, while my husband was the Alpha dog in our pack, I was next in line. We fed her last, took her for training, etc. Thank heavens it all worked. She's a fun and friendly dog. When our sons were born, she welcomed them into the fold, let them pull her ears, look in our mouth, etc. She even gets the newspaper from the driveway every morning! Her herding instinct has waned but there are times when you can see the stubborn Chow Chow in her come out...and it can be unsettling. I commend Tracy for having the courage to do the right for her family and for Maggie. I hope she can soon realize that the ashes in the closet are a testament to her deep love for Maggie; Tracy's family loved Maggie enough to let her go.

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
Amylou3111
Amylou3111 says:
July 24, 2008

We have a female cat, "Weezie", that we had spayed. as responsible cat owners do. Having only had female cats growing up, I was unaware of the magnitude of hormones from these pets. At 6 months, our new cat, a male named "Stitch" decided we all needed a biology lesson and Weezie was his target...about 20 times a day. It was then that we realized our female was still going into heat and needed to be "fixed" AGAIN!!! Needless to say, our children learned more about cats and cats than the birds and the bees. Now, both being "fixed" properly, they are like an old married couple....thank goodness!!

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
dynamicjeannie
July 23, 2008

My husband and I got a small dog shortly after our marriage. 6 years later we brought home our newborn daughter. Toby barked and barked and barked at the new arrival each time she cried. It drove us crazy and shortly after bringing home baby we were searching for a new home for the dog. We were fortunate that good friends adopted the lovely little dog, who was a great lap dog. A few years later and now with 3 children our friends brought
Toby back over to our home and all 3 of our children played with the dog in our back yard. Time had allowed this special dog the opportunity to get over the jealousy and be a loving part of another family and then come full cirle back to play with our children.

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
300x250

Your Disney Family.com profile says it all!

From Our Sponsors
Check Out These Delicious Quick & Easy Recipes
Easy Birthday Party Planner
Fun Games for the Whole Family!
Free Coupons! Just Click and Print - It's That Easy.
Disney Family Community
Please log in ...
Close
You must be logged in to use this feature.

Thank You!

Thank you for helping us maintain a friendly, high quality community at Family.com. This comment will be reviewed by a community moderator.

Flag as Not Acceptable?

We review flagged content and enforce our Terms of Use, in which content must never be:

See full Terms of Use.