728x90

Parent Moments: To Feed or Not To Feed

View Author's Profile
full star full star full star full star empty star Rated by 6 members
newborn baby
Everyone has their story. So, each week, we're going to give a prize to the person who has made the best comment to that week's featured article about the hilarity and humbling experience of raising children. Learn More

When I was first pregnant, I devoured book after book about parenting. I noticed that each author gave very different advice, sometimes conflicting, even heatedly denouncing other theories of parenting. "But surely a variety of parenting styles could co-exist," I thought to myself. "What works for one person may not work for another, and parents understand that, right?" Or so I thought.

A few weeks ago, my husband and I attended a local event with our newborn daughter, Mira. After a few hours, she was hungry and began to fuss. I looked around for a quiet corner of the convention center, and soon found a bench off the beaten path.

I felt a little nervous about breastfeeding in public, and so I pulled a blanket over her. An older woman saw me with my blanket and gently suggested, "If you keep your baby under there, she'll get too hot! She needs fresh air!"

As she walked off, I peeked under the blanket. It did seem a bit warm under there, so I removed the blanket. After all, I was angled in a way that no one could possibly see any skin unless they walked right up to me and looked down. Surely no one would mind.

But the stares began almost immediately. Looks of disdain and outright disgust were clearly visible on those walking past my bench. Even though I was feeding my baby in a way promoted by health professionals, the government, and many others, people clearly didn't want me doing it around them. One mother consciously moved to the other side of her son as they walked past, blocking him from seeing such a sight. She glanced back at me as they walked past, shaking her head with a huff. The weight of disapproving stares finally forced me to cover up with a blanket again.

Their judgmental stares were still fresh in my mind about a week later, when I took Mira to the mall. Knowing she would likely get hungry while we were out, and not wanting to provoke a similar reaction, I prepared a bottle of milk that I had pumped earlier in the day. I figured this would make the Parent Police leave me alone.

I wasn't prepared for the response I got while sitting in the food court, bottle in hand. Glancing at the mommy crew around me, I could see those same disapproving stares again. But what was I being judged for this time?

The woman at the next table struck up a conversation.

"She's cute," she began. "How old is she?"

"Oh, thanks! Five weeks," I replied.

She glanced at the bottle, hesitated for a moment, then said, "You know that breastfeeding is best, right?"

I was tongue-tied for a moment, then explained that I usually did, just not in public. She, thankfully, seemed to understand. But that didn't stop the other pairs of eyes in the room from shaking their heads at me.

These two instances of publicly feeding my daughter made me realize that when it comes to child care, no matter what you do, someone is going to judge you. Breastfeeding or formula, co-sleep or crib, organic or non-organic, public school or private -- someone's always going to disapprove of your choice, no matter how strongly you feel it's the best thing for your child.

But the fact is, there's no single, perfect way to parent, and so we must make the best choices we can for our kids, ignore the critics, and feel secure in the knowledge that we are doing the best we can.

As for me, I haven't given up on breastfeeding my daughter in public. Sometimes I do it openly, but other times I give her a bottle, depending on the situation. If I breastfeed her, I ignore the disapproving stares around me, and if anyone chooses to disagree with my choices, I smile and tell them, "Thank you for your opinion, but we're doing what works best for us."

Author BuckeyeChristy also writes about the exciting and exhausting trials of life with two young daughters on her Disney Family blog, Cirque du Mommy.

Bookmark and Share

Member Comments On...

Parent Moments: To Feed or Not To Feed

lorie4530
lorie4530 says:
August 24, 2007

It seems that today's society is very opinionated. Many times people believe that their is only right way when there are a number of ways to do something. After determining that the way something is done is indeed acceptable, the next step is finding out what "what works for us." Just because one way is better for some people, it is not the best for others. If the end result is the same, and the actions are morally, socially, and ethically acceptable, then the only people to determine the route to take, is the individuals who must complete the action.

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
brandice1981
brandice1981 says:
August 23, 2007

Wow! I guess I'm a little nieve when it comes to judgement, maybe I just don't pay attention. I was very happy when, at the end of your article, you said that while you are still experiencing the pressure of people "sharing their opinions with you" you handled the situation with perfection! Big high 5. I don't know that I would have been as polite as you were, when faced with all that negative "feedback"? I mean here you are a new parent and all these people who don't even know you or your daughter are openly critisizing you! Not to mention their exyrememly rude actions. All I can say is that you ARE right. If someone is uncomfortable witnessing a completely natural and beneficial experience for you and your child, then they can exit themselves from the situation. It sounds like you have "big shoulders" and that should serve you well as a mommy. No one's opinion matters but yours and your doctors.

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
tjennings13
tjennings13 says:
August 23, 2007

I'm sitting here with some regret & tears in my eyes over this week's article. I bottle fed my daughter & not by choice. It was a heart wrenching decision because I wanted 2 be the perfect mommy that did everything "just so". But my beautiful baby girl would have NOTHING 2 do with being breast fed & it started in the hospital when they gave her a bottle there. I was in tears. She wouldn't breast feed. She wouldn't even consider it! She would only use a bottle. I just knew I was a failure as a mommy & I had only been one for a day. We'd never bond. How could I possibly fail at something women had been doing since the beginning of time? The looks, the disapproval, the well intended comments you don't need, the stares, NONE of it matters. It all comes down 2 you & your baby. What she wants, what your gut tells you is working, & in my case, what I had 2 do 2 NOT stress out which made the baby stress out. She is a beautiful, healthy 11 year old now & the light of my life. All from a bottle.

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
300x250

Your Disney Family.com profile says it all!

From Our Sponsors
Check Out These Delicious Quick & Easy Recipes
Easy Birthday Party Planner
Fun Games for the Whole Family!
Free Coupons! Just Click and Print - It's That Easy.
Disney Family Community
Please log in ...
Close
You must be logged in to use this feature.

Thank You!

Thank you for helping us maintain a friendly, high quality community at Family.com. This comment will be reviewed by a community moderator.

Flag as Not Acceptable?

We review flagged content and enforce our Terms of Use, in which content must never be:

See full Terms of Use.