DVD Review: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
What Parents Should Know
Parents need to know that violence in this fantasy spectacle
includes countless battle casualties with death by arrows,
spears, swords, monster-stomping, fatal plunges, and
explosions. Horses as well as elephant-like beasts are killed
violently (sure, sure, they're CGI). There is quite a lot of
glorification of bladed weaponry, as well as nightmarish
imagery of ghoulish creatures, including a zombie-like ghost
army and a hideous giant spider. Heroic characters smoke, drink
and get drunk. The story starts right where the previous
Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers left off. Viewers not
familiar with the first film (or J.R.R. Tolkien's novels) will
be very confused. Not only is this Oscar winner a long movie,
the DVD "Special edition" is even longer.
- Families can talk about why they think Frodo was charged with carrying the ring.
- You can also talk about the modern-day parallels to these stories since Tolkien wrote the books as parables. And how were Tolkien's parables different from C. S. Lewis', Tolkien's longtime friend and colleague?
One of the most ambitious projects in the history of filmmaking comes to a heart-poundingly thrilling conclusion in RETURN OF THE KING, the last episode in Tolkien's Lord of the Rings trilogy directed by Peter Jackson. The second installment opened in the middle of the action, but this one begins with a flashback, in which we learn more about Gollum, the twisted, tortured creature who is supposed to be leading Frodo (Elijah Wood) and Samwise Gamgee (Sean Astin) to Mount Doom. We also learn more about the power of that ring to make anyone willing to give up all he has to possess it. After that very brief prologue, we are back where we left off, a literal cliff-hanger. Frodo, Sam, and Gollum are crossing the stark peaks on the way to the volcano in the heart of Mount Doom. That is where the ring was forged and the only place where it can be destroyed. Meanwhile, the other remaining members of the Fellowship of the Ring prepare for battle with the forces led by Sauron.
As with the first two chapters, Peter Jackson's rendition of the J. R. R. Tolkien classics is astonishing. Every detail is just right, and from the struggles of three very small creatures to stay alive as they scale sheer rock to the huge battles with hundreds of thousands of warriors, every moment is vivid, exciting, and moving. That means not just Middle earth citadels, a giant spider, and thousands of phantom combatants, but also smaller moments of equal power. Sam and Gollum each try to make Frodo mistrust the other. There are villains, grotesque and powerful, weak and greedy. And there are heroes, loyal, brave, devoted, honorable.
The tone is epic and majestic, the battles brilliantly staged, the vistas magnificently conceived. But it's still all about the story. Characters learn and deepen. Even little Pippin and Merry go from cute comic relief to genuine heroes. There is so much going on that some characters feel like not much more than cameo guest appearances, especially Arwen (Liv Tyler) and Galadriel (Cate Blanchette). And the post-ending endings, after more than three hours, may seem a bit too much. But this is still an epic to satisfy the most devoted Tolkien fans, and viewers who are new to Middle Earth. In its own way, it is as thrilling an adventure in story-telling on film as the quest it portrays.
Common Sense Media is a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing information to help parents make media and entertainment choices for their families.
Join Us