What Parents Should Know
Parents should know that this is a show about adults, for
adults. Talking about sex (and a fair amount of participating,
too) is part of the show's fabric, as is a lot of casual
drinking. Parenting skills are often trite and iffy, and the
characters use a lot of borderline-swearing language.
Families can discuss issues of loss and family relationships. Also, everyone in the show is beautiful and slender -- how hard must it be to keep up appearances? Is it realistic? How does peer pressure factor in? Can Ava and her friends really be "a family" to these orphans? Is life in a beach town really like this?
Common Sense Media Review
In the tradition of
Beverly Hills 90210
and
Melrose Place
, the California lifestyle has been nipped and tucked to
look very seductive in SUMMERLAND. Ava (played by
Lori
Laughlin, who also helped produce the series) was happily
making a name for herself in the fashion design world,
frolicking in the sunshine on the beaches of Southern
California, when her sister and brother-in-law are killed in a
car crash and she's handed three kids to care for. Ava's strong
desire to be a good person comes through in this tough
situation, but she's required to rear children in the middle of
a seemingly never-ending beach party. Like a peering into a
tide pool full of outlandish creatures, it's hard to look away
from the imaginary world of
Summerland.
But this show is perplexing to say the least. Half of the issues going on in the household are inappropriate for the kids who live there; which begs the question -- why bring kids into the mix at all? Of course, this premise is the challenge confronting the adults. But to imply that kids should watch Summerland simply because an 8-year-old and a 12-year-old are playing roles here is ridiculous. This is not family viewing. It is what junk food is to the average American -- a guilty fix for the hungry soul. Like junk food, you may crave it, but there is no substance whatsoever.
Although there are great waves to catch and an amusing time to be had trying to follow the exploits of the characters, some of the weak moral lessons can be dangerously trite. Life just isn't this shallow! Real problems like coping with the death of both parents and adjusting to a new culture are not going to disappear like the tide. And ultimately, even for all of her good intentions, Ava will never be Mom to the three kids she inherits. These kids will likely instead adopt the habits put forth by her roommates, who have not quite grown out of the idea that life ain't nothing but a party.
In short, be wary of
Summerland -- because like the song "Hotel California"
says, "you can check out, but you can never leave."
More appropriate viewing in the same vein include
Gilmore Girls
and
Degrassi, Old School
.
Common Sense Media is a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing information to help parents make media and entertainment choices for their families.



