Book Review: Malcolm X: A Fire Burning Brightly
Rate This Article
What Parents Should Know
Illustrated with vibrant illustrations, the story of Malcolm
X's life--poverty, imprisonment, struggle, and then
assassination--will enlighten rather than entertain
listeners.
Common Sense Media Review
"You don't do any singing because you're too busy swinging!"
Malcolm X jeers at Martin Luther King's nonviolent revolution
in the opening paragraph of this biography. It's admirable that
Walter Dean Myers does not soften any aspect of Malcolm's life
and words. Because of the straightforward treatment, this
picture book is clearly aimed at kids in third grade and
up.
Malcolm X has often been neglected by elementary schools, where the curriculum focuses on King. In that sense, this picture book takes an important step in acknowledging Malcolm X's message. Some readers may not agree with the civil rights leader's message, because at one time he was a thief and an advocate of violence--and by all accounts a hot-tempered man. However, the targeted age group will learn that people can change.
Quotes from Malcolm run along the bottom of many pages, enriching the narrative. Leonard Jenkins's illustrations are provocative--an interesting mix of realistic images of Malcolm against abstract backgrounds and foregrounds. The prison scene is particularly good, with abstract bars drawn over a reading Malcolm. But another, of Mecca, is so abstract that it may be hard for children to interpret.
Common Sense Media is a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing information to help parents make media and entertainment choices for their families.
