Movie Review: The Seeker
What Parents Should Know
Parents need to know that one scene in this fantasy movie
stands out as too much for younger kids: Hundreds and hundreds
of snakes attack people in a church, pursuing the teen hero to
a crypt littered with skeletons (one of which briefly comes to
life). Black birds gather in droves and attack, and Will is
constantly pursued by a dark force, most often in the form of a
masked man on horseback. The forces also threaten Will's whole
family; at one point, giant icicles rain down on them. Will
witnesses some violent events in his time travels, including
the pillaging of a medieval village and the start of a
cockfight in a tavern. In anger and frustration, he sets off a
fiery explosion. Adults drink a little ale and wine.
Families can talk about the themes in this movie that they've seen in other fantasy movies and books -- like dark riders, forces of light and dark, the gathering of signs, time travel, and reluctant heroes. Which specific books or movies does this one remind you of? Why? If kids have read the book, they can talk about the differences in this telling (expect them to be talking for a long time...).
Common Sense Media Review
Kids pining for a new
Potter-style
fantasy film epic will have to keep the vigil going. Will
Stanton, seventh son of a seventh son, seeker of the signs that
will save all from darkness, makes a fine hero in Susan
Cooper's
The Dark Is Rising
book series, but the movie adaptation is lousy. Even
though a few CGI moments are great fantasy fun, the story is so
muddled -- and so unnecessarily altered from the source
material in some ridiculous ways -- that it may make you side
with the dark forces just this once.
Will (Alexander Ludwig) is an average kid celebrating his 14th birthday as Christmas vacation starts. On his birthday, he notices some strange changes: Dogs growl at him, black birds gather in his presence, and TVs are all static when he's around. And then there are the mall security guards who threaten him, asking for "the signs," and then turn into a flock of birds as he runs for his life.
When Will's family attends a holiday party at Miss Greythorne's mansion, finally some of the strange goings-on start to make sense. Miss Greythorne (Frances Conroy), her "butler" Merriman (Ian McShane), and a few other locals are Old Ones -- time travelers/warriors who serve the Light and banish the Dark.
And they've been waiting for Will to be born for ages. He's an Old One, too and has a job to do: Find six signs before the forces of the dark take over the world. The Old Ones show him a book that will give him some guidance, but he's got to figure out the rest, traveling through time to find six signs and not giving in to the scary Dark Rider or his cronies in the process.
The signs are hidden in some ingenious places and spaces in time, and it's a nice vacation from the rest of the movie to travel there. Because when you get back to the present, you're bogged down by Will's troubled love life (his older brother is dating the girl he likes and, boy, is he mad), and a family secret about Will's father, his abandoned thesis on the light and dark, and his guilt about a family loss.
Get back to the fantasy already! Although even on that front, Will's growing relationship with the Old Ones and his realization that he's special and has a calling just isn't developed well -- maybe it's the awkward exchanges he has with Merriman, who's supposed to be his mentor but is played more for comic relief.
The movie's ending is strange and implausible, even for fantasy, and brings up all sorts of questions that future books in Cooper's series won't answer -- because it wasn't in the book to begin with.
Kids looking for better fantasy can try The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe , Howl's Moving Castle , and A Wrinkle in Time .
Common Sense Media is a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing information to help parents make media and entertainment choices for their families.
Join Us