Book Review: Maximum Ride, Book 1: The Angel Experiment
Rated by 4 members
What Parents Should Know
Parents need to know that there is a lot of violence here,
some of it quite brutal, including serious injuries. There are
broken noses and bones, knocked-out teeth, and some deaths,
guns, explosions, and car chases. Also, the marketing for this
book is pretty intense, including Blogspot and MySpace pages
and a contest to put together a tie-in music CD.
Families who read this book could discuss the idea of human and animal experimentation. Clearly the scientists are the bad guys here, but are these types of experiments ever justified? You can also discuss the book's marketing. Why the tie-in CD and Web sites? Are there different standards for book and movie marketing? Could this kind of aggressive, movie-style marketing of a book actually be a good thing, or is it just manipulative?
Common Sense Media Review
Author Patterson, best known for adult suspense novels,
makes a foray into the young adult market with this book about
a group of human/bird hybrids. For teens who just want action
and excitement (and perhaps for reluctant readers as well) and
who don't much care about the niceties, such as logic,
character development, consistent voice, or plot, this will be
plenty of fun. There's lots of gritty violence, but no sex,
drugs, or language problems to worry parents (at least those
who don't worry about gritty violence). And there's the fantasy
of winged flight, always a kid-pleaser.
The entire book amounts to little more than a prologue to the series. Despite more than 400 pages of chases, fights, break-ins, and almost non-stop action, practically nothing actually happens. They are captured, they escape, they are cornered, they escape, they are wounded, they recover, they try to hide, they are found, over and over again. Very little of it makes any kind of sense, though there are plenty of hints that it will eventually -- but not in this book. It ends, not so much with a cliffhanger, as with a lot of things set up and nothing much coming to fruition yet.
Common Sense Media is a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing information to help parents make media and entertainment choices for their families.
