What Parents Should Know
If you like doing accents and voices, this could be a great
read-aloud, which would also give you the chance to discuss
some of the more difficult parts and the clever humor.
Common Sense Media Review
Pratchett has an uncanny ability to create an unusual and
creative adventure, combine it with layers of symbolism, myth,
and cultural detail, and then wrap the whole package in the
kind of sparkling wit that rewards intelligence and careful
reading. There's a reason he's such a favorite with gifted
children and teens; as with his other novels, readers will come
away from this feeling that they've had something to chew on, a
full and varied banquet, not the usual thin gruel of ordinary
stories.
There are many delightful creations here, primarily, of
course, the Nac Mac Feegle themselves. Whenever they're on
stage, the story fairly sizzles with wit and invention. Equally
wonderful, though in a very different way, are the flashbacks
to Tiffany's Granny Aching, an old sheepherder whose hardheaded
wisdom is the product of a life lived in the chalk hills, and
is reflected in her granddaughter. And Tiffany herself, busily
clanging monsters with her frying pan while wondering about
magic, is a more than winning heroine.
In fact, one of the many unusual elements of this
unusual fantasy is that the heroes are all far more interesting
than the villains. The evil Queen and her minions have an
intentional cardboard two-dimensionality to them; they're just
nightmares, scary at times certainly, but no more. This isn't
their story, after all, and unlike so many other authors,
Pratchett doesn't lose control of them or let them take over;
he knows how to keep a villain in her place.
From the book:
She ran out of her hiding place with the frying pan
swinging like a bat. The screaming monster, leaping out of the
water, met the frying pan coming the other way with a clang.
It was a good clang, with the
oiyoiyoioioioioioinnnnnnnnngggggggg that is the mark of a clang
well done.
The creature hung there for a moment, a few teeth and
bits of green weed splashing into the water, then slid down
slowly and sank with some massive bubbles.
Common Sense Media is a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing information to help parents make media and entertainment choices for their families.

