728x90

Movie Review:
The Women

full star full star full star full star empty star Rated by 4 members
The Women -- Courtesy of Picturehouse

Rated PG-13 for sex-related material, language, some drug use and brief smoking.
Recommended for ages 14 and up
Run Time: 114 minutes
Quick Take: Mothers can find better ways to teach daughters about female empowerment than with this hollow cinematic cheerleading squad.

The Women: Lots of Chatter, Little to Say

Somewhere in Diane English's new remake of The Women, there's a message.

Maybe it's that a husband can't deliver a woman's sense of self-worth. Or perhaps it's that a woman can't fully share herself until she knows who she is. Or maybe it's that nothing says "independent woman" like an expensive salon blowout.

It's hard to tell.

The comedy slash women's-empowerment movie slash very special episode of Sex and the City would have done a whole lot better if it decided what it wanted to be. Unlike the delicious 1939 George Cukor original, which made delectable folly out of that era's clawed society dames, English's turn seems to embark on a grander plan, offering a valentine to women via four comically privileged, self-involved ladies who nevertheless bonk us on the head with messages ranging from "Women power!" to "Love your body!" to "Bitterness leads to Botox!" Talk about having your cake and...well, you know.

The remake casts Meg Ryan as Mary, curly-topped, flat-shoed earth mother and uber-wife whose life is cast adrift at the discovery that her husband is having an affair with a femme fatale (Eva Mendes). The dalliance becomes fodder for friends, family and domestic staff -- women all (the remake, like the original, is testosterone-free) -- who offer cheeky advice and one-liners about sex, facelifts and lingerie. The quartet of friends (a cinematic cliché these days) includes Sylvie (Annette Benning rehearsing for her career's second act as Christine Baranski), Alex (Jada Pinkett Smith) and Edie (Debra Messing). Along for the ride, Candace Bergen (as Mary's mom), Cloris Leachman and Bette Midler get the best lines and steal pretty much every scene they're in.

What might have been merely mediocre fluff (maybe even likeable mediocre fluff) sinks under all the empty "empowerment" speak, not to mention an unfortunate subplot about Mary's 12-year-old daughter Molly, a girl who acts out like a kid who's read a textbook on teen angst. "I hate my body," she says to Sylvie the magazine editor. "I want to look like those models in your magazine." Molly is later "cured" by her mother's new spa-toned, straight-haired, fashionista extreme makeover. (Mary, by the way, now designs clothes for sub-zero models.) Let's just say it makes you wonder about the conversations that will take place in Molly's inevitable future therapy sessions.

It might have helped if Mary's transformation appeared less superficial. Hitting bottom is a run-in with a stick of butter (one of the film's funniest moments), and an "extended" period of soul searching is illustrated by a trip to a spa, a few scribbles on a sketchpad, and a time-lapsed view of the switch to more adventurous sleepwear. The coup de grâce comes from mom who, fresh from her own face lift and so impressed with her daughter's confident and sleek new look, offers her large inheritance to finance Mary's career aspirations. Nothing says successful "independent" woman like an infusion of family money.

Except, maybe, a great blowout.

Kids Will Like:
If you can't tell from the title, this one is a girls' movie -- though only teen girls would be interested or of the right age to see it. Still, much of the inter-women chat may go over kids' heads, though they may be amused (and embarrassed) by the plain talk between these older characters. Some may be able to relate to young Molly, at least to the extent that body image at the pre-teen and teen age is tough. Moms and daughters will laugh together when Mary vividly illustrates what women will do when they need -- must have! -- junk food.

Parents Will Like:
Truly, this one's more for moms (and maybe dads) than kids. One-liners from Candace Bergen and Cloris Leachman are very funny, particularly as they pertain to cosmetic surgery. On some level, such lines spoken by cosmetically enhanced actresses sound even funnier.



Bookmark and Share

Member Comments On...

Movie Review:
The Women

family_091708
September 17, 2008

It's great. I will watch it.

0  | 
I found this helpful Thank You! Your vote will be tallied soon!
Not Acceptable?
300x250

Your Disney Family.com profile says it all!

From Our Sponsors
Please log in ...
Close
You must be logged in to use this feature.

Thank You!

Thank you for helping us maintain a friendly, high quality community at Family.com. This comment will be reviewed by a community moderator.

Flag as Not Acceptable?

We review flagged content and enforce our Terms of Use, in which content must never be:

  • Profane or sexually explicit
  • Disrespectful or abusive
  • Infringing of copyright
See full Terms of Use.