728x90
  • Daughter: Age 2
  • Leland, IL
  • Work full-time outside home
hitting
rottenweiler2000 - June 08, 2009
I am new to this site, but I have been looking for a mommy group to see if other people's kids do what my daughter does, and to find advice from moms.
I have a 20 month old that won't stop hitting. If I tell her no, she hits me. If she is playing with another kid, and the kid upsets her she hits. We have tried the one minute time outs with no success, and taking away toys. Anyone have any suggestions?
Not acceptable?
Showing 1-6 of 6

Replies to This Topic (6)

Sort by:
Newest first
Newest last
  • Son: Age 3
  • Stay at home
AnnabelleMcB - June 14, 2009

I think hitting is a stage that many kids go through, the key is to let her know the behavior is NOT tolerated!

When she hits you, be firm and strongly say no. Sit her in timeout. Make sure that your timeout isn't just on the couch in the same room with the television on. Put her on the stairs or in the hallway where there's nothing to see or do.

When she hits another child, do the same timeout. Make sure she's removed from the fun environment. If she does it a second time, it's time to leave the playdate and go home. She needs to understand there are consequences for her actions.

Continue with the timeouts and removing toys. I know it seems like it's going to last forever but I promise you it won't. As long as you make her understand that she can't get away with that behavior, she'll get tired of it eventually.


Not acceptable?
  • Group Leader
gracego80 - June 24, 2009
See Original Image
This is a problem that I am facing with my kid too .At first I used to firmly and strongly scold him .But that only got him crying so , I gave that up . I am wondering what to do !
Not acceptable?
  • Son: Age 6
  • Daughters: Ages 3 & 3
  • Stay at home
CouponsCoach - June 25, 2009
I think 20 mos is early for time-outs to work effectively, but that doesn't mean you should stop. If that's the main discipline technique you plan to use, it's a good idea to start it now. With my son, we went through the same thing and I just kept at it. It can be hard because they don't understand, but once the communication improves after age 2, usually the hitting goes away too. I think all you can do at this young age is say NO firmly and remove her, briefly. But be consistent (which is hard sometimes as a mom). You may have to do this for many many months, but it is a phase that will pass. Hang in there!
Not acceptable?
open quote Join me in the Coupon Clippers group to learn how to save big!close quote
  • Daughter: Age 3
xenozoomer - September 27, 2009

the only way to stop the hitting is to find out why they are hitting and fix the problem.

hitting is only a phase when they are little babies and around the time they experiment with gravity and the 'oops i dropped it' game.

*if the child receives spanking as a form of punishment they will not understand that hitting is bad when the parent that they see as always right and all knowing does it to them.


Not acceptable?
  • Step-son: Age 15
  • Juneau, AK
  • Stay at home
CristiAk - 1 week ago
I agree with the others. Using the same punishment every time and letting her know hitting is not tolerated are key. I also define the feeling - toddlers do not usually have the verbal skills to say what they are feeling. So along with his timeout I tell him, ' you are angry",(stressing angry and showing a mad face). I then continue with telling him that hitting hurts and making a sad face to go along with it. I tell him hitting is not allowed. I also try to note what frustrated him. I then use this in pretend play. I have his stuffed animals recreate the scene, with the ending being one animal goes to his room. In his room he hits his pillow and yells I'm so mad. It has taken us awhile but Junior is finally getting that he cannot hit. When he does it at the park, (or some other place), we leave immediately. He rarely hits in public now. I think it is important to help them learn an acceptable way to be angry. Hang in there - we have all been there. A lot more people are sympathetic than you think .
Not acceptable?
  • Daughter: Age 3
xenozoomer - 1 week ago
Replying to ...
  I think 20 mos is early for time-outs to work effectively, but that doesn't mean you should stop. If that's the main discipline technique you plan to use, it's a good idea to start it now. With my son, we went through the same thing and I just kept at it. It can be hard because they don't understand, but once the communication improves after age 2, usually the hitting goes away too. I think all you can do at this young age is say NO firmly and remove her, briefly. But be consistent (which is hard sometimes as a mom). You may have to do this for many many months, but it is a phase that will pass. Hang in there!  
By CouponsCoach
they understand at 20 months.
babies can read, add, subtract and communicate as young as 6 months old.
it needs to be explained to them how to express the anger properly and how to resolve the conflict.
saying the word "no" is limiting the childs developmental growth. the proper techniques suggest using redirection instead of "no". it is much easier for parents to just say the word "no" than to think about how to redirect or even give the child empathy. there is no such thing as terrible 2's or 3's- it is the parent that is to blame for the childs behavior.
Not acceptable?
Showing 1-6 of 6
160x600